Popular NYC Sports Bar Closes After Rent Deal Falls Through

A Beloved Institution in Murray Hill Closes Its Doors

Third Avenue in Murray Hill fell a little quieter Monday after the unexpected closing of Abbey Tavern, a popular sports bar that first opened in the neighborhood six decades ago.

Reason for Closure: Disagreement on Rent

A manager who wouldn’t share his name told Realty Check the owners of the bar couldn’t reach an agreement on rent with landlord KSR, which owns numerous commercial properties in Manhattan.

A Sign of the Times: Closure Notice

A sign posted on a door Monday announces the closure of Abbey Tavern at 354 Third Ave. Michael Nagle

A Brief History of Abbey Tavern

Abbey Tavern, opened in 1963 as a casual bar-restaurant, featured 12 large-screen TVs and was a sports-viewing mecca. Regulars preparing to gather to watch Monday’s College Football Playoff National Championship Game between Ohio State and Notre Dame were stunned by the closure.

The Evolution of Abbey Tavern

Abbey Tavern first opened on the corner in Murray Hill in 1963. Michael Nagle

In 2004, it transitioned under different owners into venues called Vertigo and Manhattan Brewhouse before the original owners took it back in 2014. They resurrected the old name but without the ships. Signs boasted of Monday-through-Friday happy hour discounts right up to the end.

The Last Hurrah

“We’re devastated,” said one customer, who declined to be named. “My wife and I came here to watch everything. Our home TV is like one-third the size of the ones here.”

When it first opened, the bar’s giant paintings of ocean liners and cozy, large booths delighted customers.

The Future of the Property

KSR posted the availability of the 4,000 square-foot corner on its website. It didn’t respond to our request for comment.

Conclusion

The closure of Abbey Tavern marks the end of an era in Murray Hill, a neighborhood that has lost a beloved institution. While many will mourn the loss, the property is now available for new occupancy, offering opportunities for future businesses to make their mark.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Why did Abbey Tavern close?
A: The owner couldn’t reach an agreement on rent with landlord KSR.

Q: When did Abbey Tavern first open?
A: 1963

Q: What was the bar known for?
A: Its 12 large-screen TVs and sports-viewing mecca

Q: What is the current status of the property?
A: The 4,000 square-foot corner is available for new occupancy, as posted on KSR’s website.