Introduction to the Crisis
The Elizabeth Street Garden is still open, but facing an active eviction notice. It hasn’t been shut down by New York City yet, but time seems to be ticking for the beloved picturesque sanctuary in Nolita.
"We’re still here. They haven’t executed a warrant of eviction so, we’re taking it day by day," said Joseph Reiver, the executive director of the Elizabeth Street Garden.
Background of the Legal Battle
There’s been a legal battle for months. The garden is on city-owned land and the city wants it back to build affordable housing. Reiver’s legal team was seeking to stop eviction with an injunction and last week a judge denied it, ruling in the city’s favor.
Now, Reiver’s preparing for the possibility of the garden being closed and fenced off, potentially by the end of March. His legal team filed an appeal.
Current Status and Community Reaction
As of late afternoon Monday, a spokesperson for NYC’s Department of Investigation (DOI) told NBC New York they were not aware of a scheduled eviction Tuesday at the garden. City marshals alert DOI one business day before a scheduled eviction.
"Yesterday there were hundreds of people coming by throughout the day expressing how much they want to save the garden," Reiver reflected. "We’re still doing everything we can, legally, politically — really everything we can because we know it’s day by day right now."
Even in the pouring rain Monday, regulars and neighbors of the garden stopped by to see if it was still open.
The City’s Plan and Community Concerns
NYC wants to turn a beloved sanctuary on the edge of Manhattan’s Little Italy into affordable housing for older New Yorkers. But supporters of the Elizabeth Street Garden say that plan’s not going anywhere, at least not yet. The little oasis boasts some big name support from the likes of Robert de Niro, Martin Scorsese and Patti Smith — but the city could serve an eviction notice at any moment.
Other longtime neighbors describe it as an escape, a sacred space where they feel peace in the middle of Elizabeth Street which is always bustling.
Katie Larson just moved a couple of blocks away and said she’s heartbroken she may not be able to fully experience the beloved haven full of sculptures and benches.
The City’s Perspective
"I know there are people who are disappointed. To that, I say I understand. I hear you," said Department of Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) Acting Commissioner Ahmed Tigani in his office on Monday.
Tigani told reporters the HPD is pleased by the judge’s decision and they’re prepared to move forward in building 123 affordable housing units for seniors, 30% for formerly homeless seniors.
"We’re not only building housing, we’re returning green space. We’re checking the boxes of our public policy," Tigani said, while encouraging people to be part of the process. "We really do encourage community members who care about the garden to come work with us to see how we can turn the 6,000 square feet of open space and make it a future bonus."
Alternative Solutions and Future Steps
Tigani says they’re watching the appeal and legal steps closely but they’re eager to get on the site once they are able to. Reiver doesn’t deny the fact that affordable housing is needed, but he’s wanted the city to take a serious look at other sites he has proposed, so that housing can be built and the garden can live on for the neighborhood.
"The mayor can still stop this, the garden is still here and those alternative sites still exist. These aren’t just city owned sites these are privately owned sites where the developers are ready and willing to work with administration," Reiver said.
To that, Tigani said given the depth of the housing crisis, they’re open to any and all sites to build housing.
"We’re not in a situation where we can choose one or the other," he said. "We’ve looked at some of the sites and suggestions they’ve made and in fact, we’re moving forward on them. If you look at 388 Hudson right now, we’re proposing a project to build hundreds of units on that site."
Conclusion
The fate of the Elizabeth Street Garden hangs in the balance as the city and its supporters await the outcome of the appeal. With the city eager to move forward with its affordable housing plan and the community fighting to save their beloved garden, the situation remains uncertain. As Reiver stated, "I still feel the weight of the community behind me and the garden and that’s what I’m focusing on."
FAQs
- Q: What is the current status of the Elizabeth Street Garden?
A: The garden is still open but faces an active eviction notice. - Q: Why does the city want to take over the garden?
A: The city plans to build 123 affordable housing units for seniors on the site. - Q: Are there alternative sites proposed for the housing project?
A: Yes, Reiver has proposed alternative sites, including privately owned ones, where developers are willing to work with the administration. - Q: What is the next step in the process?
A: The city is awaiting the outcome of the appeal filed by Reiver’s legal team, while preparing to move forward with the housing project. - Q: Can the community still save the garden?
A: The community continues to fight to save the garden, with the possibility of the mayor intervening or the appeal being successful.
