Introduction to the Beef Dispute
It’s a New York and Texas beef … over beef. And at an iconic steakhouse where history is on the menu, NYC is not backing down.
History of the New York Strip
Delmonico’s in lower Manhattan opened in 1837, eight years before Texas became a state. Presidents dating back to Abraham Lincoln and generations of Hollywood stars have dined there. And the New York Strip has always been on the menu, because that’s where it was first served up. "Steak was popular back then — New York Strip, boneless ribeye. All staples on our menu," said Dennis Turcinovic, an owner and managing partner of the storied restaurant near William and Beaver Streets in the Financial District. "The name was coined here."
The Proposed Name Change
But in an era of proposed name changes, could the Lone Star State really take over the name of the longtime menu staple? One state lawmaker certainly thinks so. Dan Patrick, the lieutenant governor of Texas, cited the large Texas cattle industry as a reason for changing the name of the popular cut — to the Texas strip. "Just because a New York restaurant named Texas beef a New York Strip in the 19th century doesn’t mean we need to keep doing that," he wrote in a post on social media.
Texas Cattle Industry
Texas has about 12.2 million head of cattle, the most in America. I met with the Texas Cattle Feeders and Cattle Raisers this week. Out of curiosity, I asked each of them their favorite cut of meat. A few said New York Strip. I asked why we didn’t call it a… — Dan Patrick (@DanPatrick) February 28, 2025
Delmonico’s Response
While Texas is a major source of beef, Delmonico’s said it sources meat from various states and countries. Delmonico’s is widely believed to be the first fine dining restaurant in the country, perhaps the first to use the term "restaurant," the first to have printed menus, the first to allow single female diners, and the first place to offer popular dishes like eggs Benedict and baked Alaska.
The Name Stays the Same
But will it be the first to change the name of the New York strip? The answer comes in a New York minute. "I think it’s ridiculous. It’s the New York strip. It will always be the New York strip. And good luck trying to change that," said Turcinovic.
Conclusion
The dispute between New York and Texas over the name of the New York strip is a battle for culinary identity. While Texas may have a large cattle industry, the name "New York strip" is deeply rooted in the history of Delmonico’s and the city of New York. It’s unlikely that the name will change, and for now, the New York strip will remain a staple of New York cuisine.
FAQs
- Q: Where was the New York strip first served?
A: The New York strip was first served at Delmonico’s in lower Manhattan. - Q: Why does Texas want to change the name of the New York strip?
A: Texas wants to change the name to "Texas strip" due to its large cattle industry. - Q: Will Delmonico’s change the name of the New York strip?
A: No, Delmonico’s has stated that the name will remain the same. - Q: What is the history of Delmonico’s?
A: Delmonico’s is widely believed to be the first fine dining restaurant in the country, with a history dating back to 1837.
