Los Angeles Homeowners Sue City to Block Historic-Cultural Monument Designation
Alleging an “abuse of power” by Los Angeles city officials, the owners of Marilyn Monroe’s former Brentwood home are suing the city to block an effort to have the structure declared a historic-culture landmark, which would prevent its demolition.
Lawsuit Alleges Illegal and Unconstitutional Conduct
The Los Angeles Superior Court lawsuit, filed Monday, alleges “illegal and unconstitutional conduct” by the city “with respect to the house where Marilyn Monroe occasionally lived for a mere six months before she tragically committed suicide 61 years ago.”
City Violated Own Codes and Procedures
The suit alleges that the city violated its own codes and procedures in pushing for the monument designation for the Helena Drive property.
Lack of Criteria for Historic-Cultural Monument
“All of these backroom machinations were in the name of preserving a house which in no way meets any of the criteria for an ‘Historic Cultural Monument,'” the lawsuit states. “That much is bolstered by the fact, among others, that for 60 years through 14 owners and numerous remodels and building permits issued by the city, the city has taken no action regarding the now-alleged ‘historic’ or ‘cultural’ status of the house.”
Plaintiffs Claim Irreparable Harm
The suit alleges the city’s actions have caused “irreparable” harm to the building’s owners and robbed them of “their vested rights as owners of real property.”
Background of the Case
The plaintiffs in the case — home owners Brinah Milstein and her husband Roy Bank — have owned the structure since July 2023 and subsequently obtained a demolition permit from the city.
After receiving numerous complaints about the planned demolition, City Councilwoman Traci Park announced in September an effort to save the house by initiating a historic-cultural monument application. The application has been working its way through the city process, receiving approval in January from the Cultural Heritage Commission and later from the council’s Planning and Land Use Management Committee.
Conclusion
The lawsuit requests a court order blocking the monument designation and allowing the plaintiffs to move forward with their planned demolition. The plaintiffs want to demolish the structure to expand their current home, which is adjacent to the property.
FAQs
Q: What is the reason for the lawsuit?
A: The owners of Marilyn Monroe’s former Brentwood home are suing the city to block an effort to have the structure declared a historic-culture landmark, which would prevent its demolition.
Q: What are the allegations against the city?
A: The lawsuit alleges that the city violated its own codes and procedures in pushing for the monument designation, and that the city’s actions have caused “irreparable” harm to the building’s owners.
Q: What is the current status of the case?
A: The lawsuit is pending in the Los Angeles Superior Court, and the matter still needs to be heard by the full City Council, which must be done by mid-June.
Q: What is the plaintiffs’ plan for the property?
A: The plaintiffs want to demolish the structure to expand their current home, which is adjacent to the property.
