Introduction to the Cell Phone Ban
A new law in Texas has sparked controversy among students and parents. The law prohibits students from using electronic devices, including smartphones, smartwatches, and tablets, during school hours. This ban has led to a heated debate about its effectiveness and potential consequences.
The Petition Against the Law
Cyliyah Goodlow, a junior at Lake Ridge High School, has started a petition to repeal the law. She believes that the ban is unfair and puts students at risk in emergency situations. The petition, which was launched on June 24, 2025, has gained significant attention and has collected over 135,000 signatures. Goodlow’s petition is not just about cell phones; it’s about being heard, being safe, and being treated with respect.
Concerns About Safety
One of the primary concerns about the cell phone ban is safety. With the rise of school shootings, many students and parents believe that having access to a phone can be a matter of life and death. In emergency situations, a phone can be a vital tool for calling for help or alerting authorities. By taking away this option, the law may be putting students at greater risk.
The Law’s Impact on Students
The law, which took effect on June 20, 2025, requires school systems to have a written policy in place by September 18, 2025. While some districts, like Houston ISD, have implemented policies that allow students to keep their phones turned off and in their backpacks, others may have stricter rules. This inconsistency can cause confusion and frustration among students.
The Need for Consultation
Goodlow believes that lawmakers should consult with students and parents before passing laws that affect them. She argues that the current law was passed without considering the potential consequences and the needs of the students. By ignoring the concerns of those who will be most affected by the law, lawmakers may be creating more problems than they are solving.
Conclusion
The cell phone ban in Texas has sparked a heated debate about its effectiveness and potential consequences. While the law’s intention is to help students, its implementation may have unintended consequences, such as putting students at risk in emergency situations. The petition started by Cyliyah Goodlow has brought attention to the issue and has sparked a conversation about the need for lawmakers to listen to the concerns of students and parents. Ultimately, the goal should be to find a solution that balances the need for safety and respect with the need for students to have access to technology. By working together, lawmakers, students, and parents can create a more effective and fair policy that benefits everyone.
