Introduction to the Issue
A Plano teacher, a Houston high schooler, and a network of LGBTQ clubs filed a federal lawsuit to block parts of a new Texas law that bans certain student groups from public schools. The law, set to take effect on September 1, bars schools from sponsoring a “student club based on sexual orientation or gender identity.” It also forbids schools from providing instruction, guidance, or programming on sexual orientation or gender identity. Schools are barred from helping in the social transitioning of a transgender child, which can include using new names or pronouns.
The Lawsuit and Its Implications
A former faculty sponsor for a Gender and Sexuality Alliance in Plano ISD; a Houston high schooler; the Gender and Sexuality Alliances Network, a nonprofit that represents GSA clubs in Texas schools; and advocacy group Students Engaged in Advancing Texas say their freedom of speech and expressive association “will be irreparably suppressed” under the new law.
The Education Lab is a community-funded journalism initiative that provides in-depth coverage of education issues and stories that affect North Texans.
The Law and Its Consequences
“S.B. 12 is one of the most extreme education censorship laws in the country, undermining the free speech rights of Texas students, parents, and educators,” said Brian Klosterboer, senior staff attorney at the ACLU of Texas, who filed the suit in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas. “We’re challenging this law in court because our schools should be places of truth, inclusion, and opportunity — not fear and erasure.” The suit names Texas Education Commissioner Mike Morath as a defendant, as well as Plano, Katy, and Houston ISDs.
Reaction from School Districts
As of Friday evening, Plano ISD had not received official notification of the suit, said Zoheb Hassanali, the district’s assistant director of communications, public relations, and social media. District leaders and legal counsel will review the matter once formally served with the legal complaint, he added. “As always, Plano ISD is committed to following all applicable state laws,” he wrote in a statement. “At the same time, our focus remains on educating our students, and we will not allow external litigation to distract us from that responsibility.” Houston ISD’s press office said the district does not comment on pending litigation.
The Legislation and Its Supporters
Rep. Jeff Leach, R-Allen, who introduced the legislation, said it ensures parents are at the “head of the table when it comes to their kids’ education.” In addition to the ban on LGBTQ clubs, the legislation requires schools to get a parent’s permission before a child can join any school club. “Our schools should be about teaching history and reading, writing, and math and civic responsibility,” Leach said as he advocated for the bill in the Legislature. “We need to get away from some of the more toxic social issues.”
The Impact on LGBTQ+ Students
The groups in the lawsuit say the ban “ostracizes” students “who have a sexual orientation or gender identity that differs from other students.” It also “harms allies of LGBTQ+ students who seek to learn about issues impacting their friends and advocate for a safer and more inclusive school environment,” according to the filing. At least one Gender and Sexuality Alliance in Plano ISD has disbanded ahead of the law’s implementation date, according to court documents. Students tried to start a new club, but school administrators said it would not be allowed. One student decided to be homeschooled because the club shut down “and the fact that their affirming name and pronouns will no longer be respected by teachers and staff,” court documents read.
Conclusion
The lawsuit against the new Texas law is a significant step in protecting the rights of LGBTQ+ students and educators. The law’s ban on LGBTQ clubs and its restrictions on instruction and guidance related to sexual orientation and gender identity have created a climate of fear and discrimination in schools. The lawsuit argues that the law violates the freedom of speech and expressive association of students, parents, and educators. As the lawsuit moves forward, it is essential to consider the impact of the law on LGBTQ+ students and the importance of creating a safe and inclusive school environment.
FAQs
Q: What is the new Texas law about?
A: The new Texas law bans schools from sponsoring student clubs based on sexual orientation or gender identity and restricts instruction and guidance related to these topics.
Q: Who filed the lawsuit against the law?
A: A Plano teacher, a Houston high schooler, and a network of LGBTQ clubs filed the lawsuit.
Q: What are the implications of the law for LGBTQ+ students?
A: The law creates a climate of fear and discrimination, ostracizes students who have a sexual orientation or gender identity that differs from other students, and harms allies of LGBTQ+ students.
Q: What is the role of the Education Lab in this issue?
A: The Education Lab provides in-depth coverage of education issues and stories that affect North Texans, including the impact of the new Texas law on LGBTQ+ students.
Q: What is the position of school districts on the lawsuit?
A: Plano ISD has not received official notification of the suit, while Houston ISD does not comment on pending litigation.
Q: What are the potential consequences of the law for schools and students?
A: The law could lead to the shutdown of LGBTQ clubs, restrict students’ ability to express themselves, and create a hostile school environment.
