Court Overturns Ex-Northwestern Professor’s Conviction for Stabbing Boyfriend to Death
Judge’s Remarks
“One of the most cold-blooded, calculated and brutal executions that he has ever seen,” the judge remarked after Lathem’s sentencing.
New Trial Ordered
The case is now headed back to trial court after an appellate court ruled that Lathem was denied access to his counsel during an overnight recess.
Reason for Overturn
“Due to the trial court’s order forbidding a testifying defendant from consulting with his attorney during an overnight recess in violation of his right to counsel, and our crystal-clear and consistent precedent on this issue, we have no choice but to reverse and remand for a retrial. As heinous as murder is, these rights are crucial to the effective administration of justice,” the court wrote in its conclusion.
Background of the Case
Cornell was stabbed 79 times in Lathem’s River North high rise. Lathem and his co-defendant Andrew Warren then drove to California before turning themselves over to police.
Co-Defendant’s Testimony
Warren testified that he flew from England to Chicago to meet Lathem and take part in a pact to kill each other before agreeing to kill the 26-year-old Cornell at Lathem’s suggestion.
Lathem’s Sentence and Apology
Lathem was sentenced to 53 years in prison in January 2022 for the murder of his boyfriend Trenton Cornell on July 27, 2017.
“I want Trent’s family to know I have been grief-stricken with remorse since the moment this happened. Every day I think about him and am filled with sadness. I can’t imagine how much worse this has been for them and I am sorry for their loss,” Lathem told the Cornell family after his sentencing.
What’s Next?
It’s unknown at this time if prosecutors will seek a new trial.
Conclusion
The overturning of Lathem’s conviction is a significant development in this high-profile case. The appellate court’s decision highlights the importance of ensuring that defendants have access to their counsel at all times, even during overnight recesses. The case is now headed back to trial court, where a new trial will be held.
FAQs
Q: What was the original sentence given to Lathem?
A: Lathem was sentenced to 53 years in prison.
Q: What was the reason for the appellate court’s decision to overturn Lathem’s conviction?
A: The court ruled that Lathem was denied access to his counsel during an overnight recess, violating his right to counsel.
Q: Will prosecutors seek a new trial?
A: It’s unknown at this time if prosecutors will seek a new trial.
